پژوهش نامه نقد آراء تفسیری

پژوهش نامه نقد آراء تفسیری

نقد آراء تفسیری ازدواج با محارم در نسل آدم ابوالبشر واکاوی سندی و دلالی روایات متعارض

نوع مقاله : مقالۀ ترویجی

نویسندگان
1 استادیار گروه علوم قرآن و حدیث مجتمع آموزش عالی شهید محلاتی
2 استادیار گروه قرآن و حدیث مجتمع آموزش عالی شهید محلاتی قم
3 دانشجوی کارشناسی ارشد علوم قرآن و حدیث دانشگاه اصفهان
10.22034/naghdeara.2026.596637.1427
چکیده
گزارش‌های روایی درباره چگونگیِ تکثیر نسل بشر در طبقهٔ دوم (فرزندانِ بی‌واسطهٔ حضرت آدم و حواء) در شمار روایات متعارض است و سه رهیافتِ متمایز در آن قابل بازشناسی است. نخست، رهیافتی که بر ازدواجِ خواهر و برادر میان فرزندانِ بلاواسطهٔ آن حضرت دلالت دارد و حرمتِ آن را تشریعی و مخصوصِ نسل‌های پسین می‌داند. دوم، رهیافتی که ازدواج با محارم را دارای حرمتِ ذاتی می‌شمارد، وقوعِ آن را میان فرزندانِ آدم ممتنع می‌داند و الگوی جانشین را ازدواج با موجوداتی از جنسِ جن یا حوریه مطرح می‌کند. سوم، رهیافتی که با استناد به روایاتِ دالّ بر وجودِ انسان‌هایی پیش از خلقتِ آدم با نام «نسناس»، تکثیر نوع بشر را بر پایهٔ ازدواجِ فرزندانِ آدم با این موجودات تبیین می‌کند. پژوهش حاضر با روشِ کتابخانه‌ای و تحلیلِ سندی ـ دلالیِ روایات، با ملاکِ تطبیقِ آن‌ها با قرآن‌کریم، به ارزیابیِ اعتبارِ آن‌ها می‌پردازد. برآیندِ ارزیابی آن است که روایاتِ حاکی از ازدواجِ فرزندانِ آن حضرت و تحریمِ تشریعیِ آن در ادوارِ بعد، هرچند سنداً ضعیف است، دلالتاً فاقدِ اشکالاتِ روایاتِ معارض بوده و به سببِ هم‌خوانی با قرآن‌کریم از پشتوانهٔ دلالیِ استوارتری برخوردار است. در مقابل، دیدگاهِ ازدواجِ فرزندانِ آدم با نسناس افزون بر ایراداتِ وارد بر روایاتِ نسناس، هیچ دلیلِ معتبری( نه روایی و نه فسیلی )بر وجودِ ارتباطِ زمانی میان نسلِ انسان و نسناس و وقوعِ ازدواجِ آنان ندارد.
کلیدواژه‌ها
موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Critique of Interpretative Views on Incestuous Marriage in the Progeny of Adam: A Chain and Semantic Analysis of Conflicting Traditions

نویسندگان English

mohammad reza shahsanaiee 1
abbas sharifi 2
enayatallah mandegari 3
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Quran and Hadith Sciences, Shahid Mahallati Higher Education Complex Qom Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Quran and Hadith, Shahid Mahallati Higher Education Complex, QomIran
3 Master's student in Quran and Hadith Sciences, University of Isfahan Iran
چکیده English

This study examines contradictory Islamic narratives about human proliferation in the second generation—the direct children of Prophet Adam and Eve. The conflicting reports fall into two main categories.

The first category consists of narrations that report the occurrence of marriage between siblings in this early generation. These texts posit that the prohibition of such unions was specific to later periods, enacted through divine legislation .

The second category includes narrations that deem such a marriage inherently and thus impossible from the outset. Instead, they propose alternative models, suggesting the children of Adam married beings from the jinn or huris.

This research employs a library-based method, applying both documentary (Sanad) analysis of transmission chains and semantic (Dalali) analysis of content. The central criterion for evaluation is the degree of conformity with the Quran's verses.

The findings indicate that the narrations of the second category, which advocate for inherent prohibition, face serious challenges. They are not only weak in their chains of transmission (Isnad) but also semantically conflict with a number of Quranic verses, rendering them lacking in necessary authenticity.

An examination of the chain of narrations related to the propagation of the human race in the second category (the direct descendants of Adam and Eve) indicates the weakness of the chain of narrations. The first group faces problems in terms of transmission in the chain and the negligence of some individuals, and the second group also faces problems due to transmission in the chain. However, from the point of view of interpretation, the first group of these narrations, which emphasizes the inherent prohibition of marriage with incestuous people and the occurrence of marriages between the children of Adam (peace be upon him) and angels and jinn, contradict many verses of the Holy Quran. Among these verses are verses that consider the propagation of the human race only from Adam and Eve (An-Nisa-1), verses that deny gender from angels and emphasize that the process of propagation of the human race was carried out from one male and female gender (27 Najm, 19 Zukhruf, and 13 Hujurat). Or verses such as 59 Al-Imran, which considers the only unnatural creation in the descendants of Prophet Adam to be specific to Prophet Jesus (peace be upon him), and verse 47 Al-Imran, which implicitly considers the multiplication of the human race to be possible only through humans. In addition, the lack of mention of this group of narrations in the interpretations of Shiite commentators before the promotion of Akhbarism is a clue to the weakness of this group of narrations in the view of early Shiite commentators. The third view, which implies the marriage of the children of Prophet Adam (peace be upon him) with previous humans, also lacks the necessary solidity because it lacks a valid reason from the perspective of narration and archaeological excavations and is not defensible. In this view, apart from the problems with the principle of the existence of lineage and the complete physical and spiritual similarity with the descendants of Prophet Adam (peace be upon him), no evidence, including narrations and archaeological excavations, has been presented for any connection between the descendants of Prophet Adam (peace be upon him) and them. But the second view, which considers marriage with incest to be a legal prohibition, not an intrinsic one, and considers its occurrence in the direct descendants of Prophet Adam (peace be upon him) to be legal and permissible before the prohibition, is, from a declaratory point of view, devoid of any conflict with the verses of the Holy Quran and in this respect is preferable to the first group. In addition, this view is also consistent with a group of narrations of the Ahl al-Bayt (peace be upon them). Therefore, it seems that this view is in accordance with reality.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Progeny proliferation
marriage with close relatives
Children of Prophet Adam (peace be upon him)
inherent prohibition (Hurma Dhati)
legislative prohibition (Hurma Tashri'i)

مقالات آماده انتشار، پذیرفته شده
انتشار آنلاین از 27 آبان 1405

  • تاریخ دریافت 14 مهر 1405
  • تاریخ بازنگری 27 آبان 1405
  • تاریخ پذیرش 27 آبان 1405